10 Red Flags When Dating in Your 50s

Dating in your 50s can be an exciting prospect. Connecting with and meeting new people, the butterflies fluttering in your stomach, a mix of nervousness and hope, first dates, blossoming romance. It can all leave you feeling giddy, almost like a teenager. As you navigate this new chapter, it becomes imperative to keep your eyes open for potential red flags. What do these red flags when dating in your 50s look like? We help you decode, in this article, along with tips on how to handle them, so you can protect yourself while enjoying the dating journey.

10 Red Flags When Dating in Your 50s

Despite the mix of excitement and uncertainty, you may feel more confident navigating the dating world in your 50s. After all, you’re wiser, more self-aware, and likely know what you want in a partner. But that doesn’t mean the path is free of pitfalls, and often, this confidence can become a blind spot red flags when dating in your 50s. 

Whether you’re newly single or giving love another shot after a long break, it’s important to spot the warning signs early. Red flags aren’t always glaring; sometimes they’re subtle behaviors that chip away at your peace of mind over time. In this article, we’ll dive into the most common dating red flags to watch out for in your 50s, so you can protect your heart, your time, and your energy.

1. They won’t talk about their past

At 50+, everyone has a history, whether it’s a divorce, the loss of a spouse, or significant past relationships. If your date refuses to share anything about their past or gets defensive when you ask simple questions, take note. This is one of the most common emotional red flags in mature dating. A healthy relationship requires a basic level of openness. If the person you’re dating just refuses to let their guard down or let you in, how can you build a solid connection with them? 

Related Reading: 8 Expert Tips To Let Go Of The Past And Be Happy

What to do

Try gently encouraging them to share by opening up about your own past. If they still dodge every question or have obvious inconsistencies in their stories, consider it a red flag​. Lifelong secrecy or unresolved issues might mean they’re not ready for a genuine, trusting partnership.

2. Financial secrecy or pressure

Dubious behavior around money is one of the most prominent online dating red flags for seniors because by now, you likely have significant assets and your life’s savings that you’re depending on to see you through your silver years. You wouldn’t want to jeopardize that in the quest of finding love or companionship.  

If someone is very secretive about their finances, exhibits drastic spending that doesn’t add up, or, worst of all, starts asking you for loans or financial help early on, be wary​. Sadly, romance scams are on the rise. In 2023 alone, more than 64,000 people reported being victims of romance scams, with losses totaling $1.1 billion​ ncoa.org. Many scammers target older singles by spinning stories about financial hardship or “investment opportunities.” 

What to do

Protect your financial information. If a match online steers conversation toward cryptocurrency or quick investment schemes, follow the lead of savvy daters like one woman who recognized a “Bitcoin scammer” and cut off contact immediately​. Stick to reputable dating platforms and never send money to someone you’ve just met. Using well-known dating sites such as OurTime or SeniorMatch, both geared toward over-50 singles or established services like Match or eHarmony can provide an extra layer of safety and verification.

Related Reading: Financial Infidelity—Definition and Signs

3. Unresolved baggage and bitterness

By fifty-something, many of us have ex-spouses or long-term relationships in the rearview mirror. It’s normal to have some lingering feelings, but listen to how your date talks about their exes. Are all their former partners described as “crazy” or “awful”? Do they seem consumed by anger or blame? An excess of bitterness could indicate unresolved emotional baggage that they may carry into a new relationship​. 

What to do

Encourage honest communication about past experiences, but if someone is clearly stuck in the past or habitually bad-mouthing an ex, be cautious. You deserve a partner who is ready to move forward, not someone trapped in old drama.

4. Incompatible life patterns

Wondering, what not to ignore when dating in your 50s? Your respective lifestyles. It may seem like a small thing early on, but it’s important to factor it into your dating decisions because by this age, people have established routines and lifestyles. Maybe you’re an early bird who loves grandkids and gardening on weekends, while they’re a night owl who lives for spontaneous travel. 

Some differences add spice, but major lifestyle incompatibilities can be a red flag if neither party is willing to compromise​. For instance, if you’re looking forward to retirement in a few years and they insist they’ll never stop working, or vice versa, conflicts may loom. 

Related Reading: What Are Relationship Flaws And How To Deal With Them

What to do

Have candid conversations about lifestyle early on, touching upon topics like health habits, work-life balance, and leisure activities. If you notice a stark clash (say, they dislike that you’re close with your children or they have hobbies you find unacceptable), don’t brush it aside hoping they’ll change. Relationship experts say that it’s wise to identify your top deal-breakers in advance​. Knowing what truly matters to you will help you spot red flags of deep incompatibility sooner.

5. Lack of independence (looking for a caregiver)

It’s wonderful to support each other in a relationship, but be careful if your date seems to want a caretaker more than an equal partner. Some people in their 50s might be seeking a “nurse or purse”, someone to take care of them or fund their lifestyle. Life coach Elizabeth Hudson warns that an older woman dating a much younger man who isn’t “in his masculine power” may end up slipping into a parental role​. In one case, her client found herself mothering a boyfriend—finding him jobs and paying for trips—while he complained and showed little personal responsibility​. 

What to do

Notice if they rely on you for basic adult tasks or decisions, or if they push responsibilities onto you quickly. A healthy 50+ relationship should be a partnership of two independent adults. If you sense they’re looking for a “parent” or a caregiver rather than a companion, set some boundaries. It’s okay to lend a supportive ear, but you shouldn’t have to raise a grown person.

6. Disrespecting your boundaries 

To spot red flags when dating in your 50s, pay attention to how the person you’re dating reacts when you set normal boundaries—whether it’s saying you’re not ready to become exclusive yet, or that you prefer to meet at a public place, or even something small like declining a second drink. Someone who pushes past your comfort zone early on is waving a red flag​. In your 50s, you likely have family obligations, a career, or routines that demand respect. 

What to do

Stand firm on setting healthy boundaries. A mature partner will respect them. If they don’t—for example, if they insist “you must not care about me” just because you maintain separate hobbies or time with friends—reconsider proceeding. Healthy love honors personal space and prior commitments.

Related Reading: 11 Examples Of Unhealthy Boundaries In Relationships

7. Poor communication or dishonesty

Does your new flame dodge direct questions or give you the runaround? This is, without a doubt, an early warning sign that you won’t be able to build a wholesome, secure relationship with this person. That’s why, if you’re wondering what not to ignore when dating in your 50s, keep patterns like poor communication and dishonesty on your radar.

Effective communication is the cornerstone of any relationship, especially in midlife​. Inconsistent behavior like saying one thing and doing another, or stories not adding up, amount to mixed signals that can leave you anxious and confused. 

What to do

Don’t ignore it if their words and actions frequently clash. At 50+, you’ve honed your intuition. Trust it. Repeated inconsistency or evasiveness might indicate they’re not fully committed or even hiding something​. Bring up your concerns in a calm, direct way. If they dismiss your feelings or continue the behavior, it may be time to walk away.

8. Emotionally unavailable

Some singles in their 50s have been alone a long time or are freshly out of a relationship and not truly ready to let someone in emotionally. Emotional red flags in mature dating might include a reluctance to express feelings, keeping you at arm’s length, or explicitly saying they “don’t want anything serious” while still enjoying all the benefits of your companionship. If you sense a wall around their heart, proceed with caution. 

What to do

You can enjoy casual dating if that’s what you want, but if you’re looking for a deeper connection and they aren’t, don’t try to force it. Listen if they tell you—directly or through their actions—that they can’t provide emotional intimacy. As hard as it is, you’re better off not investing your heart in someone unavailable to receive it​.

9. Jealousy or isolation tactics

One of the most prominent red flags when dating in your 50s is that the person you’re with tries to isolate you from your friends and family or displays unreasonable jealousy. By our 50s, we usually have important long-standing relationships with children, siblings, and friends. If your date makes snide remarks about your loved ones or pressures you to cut back contact with them, beware​. For example, Elizabeth recounts a client whose boyfriend even competed with her teen daughter for attention, whining about not getting the same treats the daughter did​. That kind of behavior isn’t just immature, it’s a sign of potential control issues. 

Related Reading: How To Deal With Jealousy In Relationships

What to do

Make it clear your family and friends are integral to your life. A loving partner will want to get along with the people you care about, not compete with them. Don’t tolerate someone who tries to drive a wedge between you and your support network.

10. They’re too good to be true

If in the first few dates someone is showering you with extreme praise, intense declarations of affection, and grand promises for the future, slow down. Sure, it’s flattering to hear, “You’re the best thing that ever happened to me.” But if it’s only week two, it’s among the early warning signs of unhealthy relationships after 50. 

Seasoned scammers and manipulators often use love bombing to lower your guard. As Elizabeth says, “There’s practically an “army” of smooth talkers out there who prey on singles over 50 by assuming they are desperate, which, by the way, you are not!”​ If someone claims “I’ve never met anyone like you” and wants to rush into exclusivity or even financial entanglement immediately, run for the hills. This is the simplest answer on how to avoid scammers when dating online over 50.

What to do

Pace the relationship. Insist on getting to know each other in a balanced way. Genuine love will respect your caution. If friends or family raise concerns about someone’s overly fast and furious courtship, listen to them​. Those who care about you might spot phony behavior that’s hard to see through rose-colored glasses.

Final Thought—Trust Your Instincts

In your 50s, you’ve built up life experience – use it. Red flags might appear as a gut feeling that “something’s off.” Perhaps their stories don’t quite line up, or you notice how poorly they treat waitstaff. Don’t dismiss these small warning signs. Most importantly, don’t let loneliness or excitement cloud your judgment. It’s absolutely possible to find love again in midlife – many do, and you should remain hopeful. Just remember that a healthy relationship will add to your happiness, not create constant worry.

If you encounter any of these red flags while dating, step back and evaluate. You might have a conversation to address the issue, or you might decide to move on. By being aware of the warning signs and trusting yourself, you can more confidently navigate the dating scene. After all, dating over 50 should be fun and enriching. Keep your standards high, use common sense (for instance, meet new dates in public places and tell a friend where you’re going), and don’t rush into anything that doesn’t feel right. With a little caution and a lot of self-respect, you can avoid the major pitfalls and focus on the potential red roses instead of the red flags.

Men Over 50 – 11 Lesser Known Things Women Should Know

Best Mature Dating Apps and Sites for Singles over 40s, 50s

9 Best Safe Dating Sites For Over 50

Your contribution does not constitute a charitable donation. It will allow Bonobology to continue bringing you new and up-to-date information in our pursuit of helping anyone in the world to learn how to do anything.