First Love Theory: Is It True Men Never Forget Their First?

Spread the love

First love…giddying, intense, passionate, and often all-consuming. There is no denying that the first brush with romantic love has a lasting impact on people. Given that most people experience first love in their teen years, it rarely grows into a lasting relationship. Even so, first loves do shape our patterns in relationships—both good and bad—and are certainly hard to forget. However, the first love theory goes a step further and suggests that men never actually get over the first person they fall in love with.

They always hold a special place for their first love in their heart and even measure up all future partners against them. Now, that can put a serious dampener on a lot of relationships. If you’re not your partner’s first love, you may find yourself wondering if they’re holding a candle for someone else while they go through the motions of a relationship with you and can stir up a lot of insecurity.

That’s why we decided to delve deeper into men’s first love theory and figure out if there is any merit to it after all, based on recent research and studies in the area as well as insights from leading psychologists and relationship experts. So, do men get over their first love? Let’s find out.

What Is Men’s First Love Theory?

Table of Contents

Men’s first love theory suggests that a man’s initial romantic experience profoundly influences his future relationships and perceptions of love. This early encounter often leaves a lasting emotional imprint, shaping how he views intimacy and commitment. That’s because when a person falls in love for the first time, their brain undergoes significant changes. Research indicates that romantic love activates areas associated with motivation and reward, similar to the effects of addictive substances.

This intense experience can set a benchmark for future relationships—it’s a classic case of a past relationship affecting the present and future. As psychologist Jefferson Singer notes, experiences from ages 15 to 26 are particularly memorable, making first loves during this period especially impactful. This initial love often becomes a template against which a man measures future partners. Traits from their first love can influence their attraction patterns, sometimes leading them to seek similar qualities in others. However, this comparison can also hinder new relationships, if a person is constantly measuring their present partner against an idealized past.

It’s common to feel a sense of nostalgia when reminiscing about one’s first love. These memories can evoke strong emotions, reminding a person of a time when feelings were fresh and intense. While cherishing these memories is natural, it’s essential to recognize that personal growth and changing circumstances mean that not all aspects of that first love are relevant to the present.

Related Reading: How To Get Over Your First Love: 13 Expert-Backed Ways

A Reddit user, who thinks her first love is still not over her, offers an interesting perspective on the first love theory, and says, “In my experience my first love is not over me. We were together from 16 to 20. When I got divorced at 27 (married at 22, way too young), the first love texted me some really unfortunate uncomfortable low key sad (pathetic but I hate to say that since he’s clearly just emotionally unhealthy) stuff about missing me blah blah blah. I’m 30 now and he’s still doing the same thing.

“He’s not still in love with me like he thinks he is. I’m no where near the person I was in my teens. And we haven’t seen each other or spoken person to person since we were 20. He’s stuck on an idea of me and there’s nothing I can do to help him drop the delusion. That’s all on him. But as I’ve said, this screams emotionally stunted. And that’s going to vary person to person. My current BF is the best man I know. Emotionally mature and available. Married once before very young like me and has no feelings for anyone in his past. We are fully each other’s. These two men are very different and therefore healed and grew differently.”

Is The First Love Theory Only Applicable To Men?

While the first love theory is generally used in reference to men’s experience with first love, it’s not necessarily gender-specific. The answer to what does first love mean to a girl is not very different from what does first love mean to a guy. The first romantic experience leaves a deep emotional imprint on men and women alike. However, there is evidence to suggest that men may process and remember their first love a bit differently than women.

In a majority of cultures, men are conditioned to suppress their emotions, and so, when a guy is vulnerable and experiences deep feelings for the first time, it can be especially impactful. Psychologist Nancy Kalish, who studied rekindled romances, found that men tend to idealize their first love more than women, holding onto memories and emotions for longer. She suggests that because men may not have had as many emotional outlets, their first love becomes a powerful reference point.

men's first love theory — First love affects people in unique ways

That said, women also form strong emotional connections with their first love. For them, it might serve as a learning experience or a foundation for understanding future relationships. Ultimately, first love affects people in unique ways, but the emotional weight it carries is a shared human experience. Whether you’re a man or a woman, those early feelings can linger, influencing how you approach love long after the relationship has ended.

Related Reading: You Fall In 3 Types Of Love In Your Life : Theory And Psychology Behind It

Why Is First Love So Powerful?

Whether you think about what does first love mean to a girl or what does first love mean to a guy, there is no denying that first loves hold a unique and enduring power over us, influencing our emotions and relationships in profound ways. Let’s delve deeper into the psychology of first love to understand why it is so:

1. Neurological imprinting

When you fall in love, your brain releases a combination of neurotransmitters, such as dopamine, oxytocin, and serotonin, that create feelings of euphoria and attachment. Biological anthropologist Helen Fisher’s fMRI studies have shown that romantic love activates the brain’s reward system, similar to the effects of addictive substances. When you experience this for the first time, this biochemical response gets deeply imprinted into your memory, making it a reference point for future relationships.

2. Developmental significance

psychology of first love — Feelings of intense first love remain etched into your psyche

First loves often occur during adolescence, a critical period for emotional and psychological development. Cognitive scientists at MIT explain that we experience peak processing and memory power at around age 18, making experiences during this time particularly impactful. That’s why your first relationship based on feelings of intense love remains etched into your psyche.

3. Idealization and uniqueness

The novelty of first love leads to idealization, where you perceive the relationship as perfect or unique. This idealization is a key aspect in the psychology of first love and its lasting impact on a person’s choice in adult relationships. Author Rosemary Rogers captures this sentiment, stating, “First romance, first love, is something so special to all of us, both emotionally and physically, that it touches our lives and enriches them forever.”

Related Reading: When I Saw My First Love Years Later

4. Cognitive biases

Research suggests that our first crush is not only hard to get over but also shapes our romantic preferences. Cognitive biases have a role to play in this tendency. During first love, cognitive biases like the halo effect and confirmation bias are heightened, causing a person to focus on positive traits of their romantic interest and overlook flaws. These biases intensify the emotional experience, making it more memorable.

5. Emotional resilience and growth

Experiencing first love and its potential loss contributes to emotional resilience. It teaches you about vulnerability, empathy, and the complexities of human connections, which are essential for personal growth. For a lot of people, their first love is closely tied to their first heartbreak, which can be an excruciatingly painful and often life-altering emotional event. The way a person navigates these ups and downs can become an emotional blueprint for how they steer through similar situations later in life.

Is It True That Men Never Forget Their First Love?

The notion that men never forget their first love has been a topic of both popular culture and academic research. While some studies suggest that early romantic experiences can leave lasting impressions, the idea that men are uniquely or universally unable to move past their first love is not conclusively supported by scientific evidence.

Research indicates that first loves can significantly influence future romantic preferences. For instance, early emotional experiences may create a “romantic blueprint,” leading individuals to seek out partners with traits reminiscent of their initial love. This phenomenon underscores the lasting impact of early attachments on one’s romantic life. However, it’s essential to recognize that the intensity and duration of attachment to a first love can vary widely among individuals.

Related Reading: I Realised In My Adulthood Why They Call It Puppy Love

You cannot stereotype the dynamics of men and love. A lot of men may look back at their first loves with disdain, some may remember their first relationship fondly but without harboring any lingering feelings for their former partner, and some may view the experience as a life lesson in what to do and what not to do in relationships. Take the example of this Reddit user, who discredits men’s first love theory, and says, “Oh god no. If I was still with my first love I’d be miserable or divorced. I was also a shitty and inexperienced partner, which coupled with her mental instability was a recipe for disaster long term.” He goes on to add:

Another user has a similar experience to share:

This has also been the takeaway of Nancy’s research into rekindled romances. She found that while some people maintain a profound connection to their first love, others do not experience the same enduring attachment. This variability suggests that personal factors, rather than gender alone, play a significant role in how first loves are remembered and valued.

Besides, societal norms and expectations can influence how men process and express emotions related to past relationships. Traditionally, men have been encouraged to suppress emotional vulnerability, which might affect how they internalize and recall their first romantic experiences. However, contemporary shifts toward emotional openness are challenging these norms, leading to a more nuanced understanding of how men reflect on past loves.

Key Pointers

The intensity of first love creates a “romantic blueprint,” shaping future relationships and attraction patterns
Research suggests men tend to hold onto memories and emotions of their first love longer, often due to fewer emotional outlets
Many men move on, with personal growth and individual experiences playing a more significant role than gender alone
Cultural expectations around masculinity may lead men to suppress emotions, potentially making their first love feel more impactful

Final Thoughts

So, do men get over their first love or does the first love theory hold water? While first loves often hold a special place in people’s memories (men and women alike), the assertion that men universally never forget their first love isn’t categorically true. Individual differences, societal influences, and personal growth trajectories all contribute to how first loves are remembered and integrated into one’s life narrative.

Love Takes Its Time To Develop And Grow

12 Signs Of Infatuation You Mistake For Love – Again And Again

Limerence vs Love | Difference And Signs To Know

Your contribution does not constitute a charitable donation. It will allow Bonobology to continue bringing you new and up-to-date information in our pursuit of helping anyone in the world to learn how to do anything.