Safety for Online Dating: Secure Messaging & Privacy Tips for NYC Singles

Online dating in New York City can be a thrilling adventure given the sheer number of opportunities at your disposal. You come across an eclectic mix of people in your online dating journey, and that can be an enriching experience in more ways than one. As you soak up this experience, don’t forget to prioritize your privacy and safety for online dating. Meeting and connecting with so many people online brings in its wake some unique risks: scammers trying to steal your money, creeps misusing personal info, or worse. 

We have put together this guide on dating safety practices to help you thwart those risks, protect your privacy, and communicate securely on dating platforms. We’ll cover why safety is essential (spoiler: almost half of online daters have faced some form of harassment or scam) and then dive into practical online dating safety tips to keep your messages and personal data secure. Whether you’re swiping for casual fun or a long-term partner, a little precaution goes a long way toward a worry-free love life.

Why You Need to Prioritize Safety in Online Dating

First, let’s talk about why prioritizing safety for online dating is non-negotiable. Well, because a digital romance can quickly turn into a nightmare without proper safety measures, exposing you to scams, data leaks, and emotional heartbreak.

Online dating comes with real dangers that aren’t just urban legends. The statistics and stories are eye-opening. For starters, scammers are rampant. According to Pew Research, about half of Americans who’ve used dating sites (52%) think they encountered a scammer at some point. In fact, 64,000+ romance scam reports were filed with the FTC in 2023 alone, with victims losing $1.14 billion in total—the highest losses of any impostor scam category. These scams often involve someone pretending to fall in love, only to spin a sob story and ask for money. 

Beyond scams, harassment, and privacy abuses are disturbingly common in the online dating world. A Pew Research study found that 48% of dating app users have experienced at least one major unwanted behavior, like unsolicited explicit images, persistent stalking after they said no, or even threats of physical harm. Women, especially under 50, face the brunt of this—over 56% of young women have been sent unwanted sexual material on dating apps. 

These interactions aren’t just “annoying”; they can be traumatic and create a climate of fear. “We’ve learned that dating apps can be far from safe,” warns cybersecurity researcher Oded Vanunu, after finding severe security flaws in popular dating app, OkCupid. Yes, your personal data can be at risk: hackers and snoops target dating platforms because of the sensitive info on them. In one 2023 incident, a misconfigured database for a dating app exposed data on 2.3 million users, including names, emails, plain-text passwords, private photos (even intimate images), and sensitive health details like STD status. Cybersecurity experts note this trove could easily fuel identity theft, blackmail, or stalking attacks against users. It’s a chilling reminder that what you share online can fall into the wrong hands if the platforms you sign up for don’t safeguard it. 

Finally, prioritizing safety is literally life and death in some cases. There have been real-world assaults linked to online dates, including in and around NYC. In one case, a New Jersey man posed as a nurse on dating apps to lure women, then kidnapped and attacked at least four victims when they tried to break things off; he was sentenced to 10 years in prison in 2025. And it’s not just one bad apple: police investigations and news reports have uncovered many instances of predators using dating apps to find targets for robbery or worse. These incidents, while rare, underline an important truth: once you move from messaging to meeting, the stakes become very high. Your safety and security at every step of the way, right from entering your details on a dating app to navigating dates with your matches, are in your hands. 

Taking online dating safety seriously isn’t overreacting; it’s essential self-care. From protecting your messages and photos to guarding your heart and bank account, a few smart steps can prevent a world of trouble. Below, we’ll cover secure messaging and privacy tips specifically tailored for NYC singles to help you swipe, chat, and meet more safely. Stay vigilant, and you can enjoy the fun parts of dating without the unnecessary risks.

8 Crucial Secure Messaging & Privacy Tips for NYC Singles

Protecting yourself online doesn’t mean killing the romance or being paranoid. It just means setting some healthy boundaries and using technology wisely. Here are eight crucial tips to boost your messaging security and privacy on dating platforms. Follow these, and you’ll be far less likely to become another dating horror story headline, and more likely to enjoy your NYC dating adventures with peace of mind.

1. Don’t share too many personal details early on

It’s tempting to open up to a charming new match, but oversharing personal information too soon can put your privacy at risk. The more details a stranger learns about you, the more easily they can find you outside the app or misuse that info. Scammers and creeps often fish for details that could help them manipulate or track you. Stay in control of your story: you can be authentic and real without divulging sensitive data in the first few chats.

• Keep identifiers minimal: Use just your first name or even a nickname on your dating profile. Avoid listing your last name, exact workplace, or social media handles publicly. This makes it harder for someone to look you up or cross-reference you before you’re comfortable. As relationship therapist Sarah Kyle advises, “Don’t share personal details such as your workplace, home address, or information about your children before really getting to know the person.” Save those specifics for when you’ve built mutual trust
• Hide clues in photos: Be mindful of what’s visible in your pictures. Family last names on graduation diplomas hanging on your wall, your street address visible on your house, or even a uniform that shows your company’s name can all give away more than you intend. Crop or blur out truly identifying details, or just pick different images
• Use in-app calling or a secondary number: When you decide to talk or text outside the dating app, consider using a free Google Voice number or a messenger app like WhatsApp or Signal instead of your real cell number. This way, if things go south, you can cut off contact without the person having your primary phone number. It’s an easy layer of privacy, especially in NYC, where your phone number can be tied to payment apps or other info
• Guard your social media until ready: Linking your Instagram or Facebook to your dating profile might seem normal, but remember that those accounts often have your full name, friends/family, and years of personal content. Think twice before connecting them. Once you truly trust someone, you can share your social media, but there’s no rush

2. Use secure networks and a VPN for dating apps and chats

One of the most effective online dating safety tips is to always use a secure internet connection, or better yet, a VPN when swiping or messaging. Public Wi-Fi at coffee shops, libraries, or subway stations can be hazardous to your privacy. These networks are usually unencrypted, meaning hackers on the same network can potentially “eavesdrop” on what you’re doing. The last thing you want is someone intercepting your login credentials or personal messages while you’re flirting online. Even at home, a nosy roommate or a weak router password could expose your activity.

• Avoid public WiFi for sensitive tasks: If you’re out and about in NYC and just have to check that dating app, consider using your phone’s data plan rather than public WiFi. Or, if you must use public WiFi, never log in to your dating accounts or share personal info on it without extra protection
• Use a trusted VPN: A VPN (Virtual Private Network) is a simple tool that encrypts your internet connection. It’s especially useful on public networks, essentially creating a secure “tunnel” for all the data from your device. This means even if someone intercepts traffic, they can’t read it. A tried and tested app like NordVPN on your phone and computer will scramble your data (messages, photos, and so on) and also hide your IP address, which conceals your approximate location and identity online
• Secure your home WiFi: Don’t forget about your own network. Make sure your home Wi-Fi router has a strong password and up-to-date security with WPA2 or WPA3 encryption. This prevents strangers in your vicinity from snooping. While it’s unlikely someone’s wardriving outside your Brooklyn apartment for your dating app chats, good WiFi hygiene protects all your online activities
• Keep apps and OS updated: Using secure networks won’t help if your device itself has vulnerabilities. Always install the latest updates for your dating apps and your phone’s operating system – those patches often fix security issues that hackers could exploit. For instance, older versions of Android had known flaws that could let attackers access stored data like saved messages. Staying updated is an easy safety win.

3. Protect your dating accounts with strong security

Your dating profile, like any other account, can be hacked or misused if you don’t secure it properly. Imagine a criminal gaining access to your dating account: they could see private messages, personal photos, or even impersonate you to scam others. In worst cases, if you reuse passwords, a breach of your dating app could open the door to your email or bank accounts. Treat your dating app logins with the same care as online banking. A few precautions will keep the only person logging in you.

• Use a unique, strong password: Don’t ever reuse the password from your email, social media, or any other account on your dating app. Use a completely unique passphrase that’s hard to guess, like a string of random words or an alphanumeric mix. Password managers can help generate and store these. This way, even if the dating app’s database gets compromised, hackers can’t use that password to try to get into your other accounts
• Enable two-factor authentication: Check if your dating platform offers 2FA via SMS code or an authenticator app. Enabling it means even if someone somehow steals your password, they still can’t log in without the second factor (like a code sent to your phone). It’s an extra 10-second step for you, but a huge roadblock for attackers. Given how many fake profiles and bots float around, 2FA also ensures it’s really you accessing your account.
• Beware of phishing and fake logins: Be cautious of emails or messages claiming to be from the dating app that ask you to “verify your account” or “log in” via a link. Scammers sometimes send phishing emails that look legitimate to steal your credentials. Always log in through the official app or website, not via emailed links. And never give your login info to someone else. No genuine date or “customer support” will ever need your password
• Log out on shared devices: If you ever use a public computer or a friend’s phone to check your dating profile, log out when done. Also, use your phone’s lock screen security. You wouldn’t want a nosy friend or a thief who snatches your phone to have instant access to your dating app. A PIN, fingerprint, or face lock on your device adds a barrier in case of physical snooping

4. Stay on the dating app for chatting until you trust your match

We get it, once you hit it off with someone, there’s often a rush to move off the dating app and text on WhatsApp or exchange numbers. But there’s safety in staying on the app’s messaging platform, at least for the early stages of getting to know someone. Dating apps have built-in protections: you can easily block or report someone abusive, and they have limited info about you. The moment you move to a personal channel, you’re more exposed. Scammers also often try to migrate conversations off-platform quickly because it’s harder for them to be detected or banned there. So,

• Don’t be rushed off-app: A genuine person will understand if you say you prefer to keep chatting in-app for a bit. If someone immediately insists on taking the conversation off-app, consider why. It’s often a red flag. Perhaps they’ve been kicked off the app before or have ill intentions. Take your time; a real connection won’t evaporate just because you haven’t swapped numbers on day one
• Use app features like video chat: Many dating services offer in-app video call or voice call features. This is a great way to verify someone’s identity and vibe without giving out your phone number or social media. Schedule a quick video date through the app. It not only confirms that the person looks and sounds like who they claim to be, but it also keeps the communication within a safer, moderated environment
• Leverage safety tools: Apps are increasingly adding safety features. For example, some apps let you blur explicit images by default or use AI to detect harassing language. Others partner with services for background checks on matches, or have panic buttons if a date goes bad. When you stay on the app, you benefit from these tools. If you shift to regular texting, you’re on your own
• When you do switch, still protect info: Eventually, you might feel comfortable enough to move to phone/text or another chat app. Even then, consider using a secondary number like Google Voice or a chat app that doesn’t reveal your personal details 

5. Watch out for scams, catfishing, and red flags

Not everyone on dating apps is who they say they are. Scammers often create fake profiles to exploit people looking for love. They might steal photos from a model or a real person’s account, fabricate a life story, and then play on your emotions. The end goal is usually money, but some may seek compromising photos or personal data for blackmail. Apart from scammers and catfish, there is also the risk of coming across toxic or manipulative behavior on these apps. It’s crucial to keep your guard up and recognize the warning signs before you get hurt.

• Never send money or gifts: This is worth stating loud and clear. No matter how sweet or genuine someone seems, if they ask for money, don’t do it. The FTC reports that 24% of romance scam reports involved lies about illness, injury, or jail. Do not wire money, send gift cards, or transfer crypto to someone you’ve never met. If you feel compelled to help, talk to a friend first; outside perspectives help break the emotional spell
• Verify with a reverse image search: If you suspect a profile might be fake because their behavior is sketchy or they seem too good to be true, do a quick reverse image search of their profile picture. Tools like Google Images or TinEye can show if that photo is all over the internet or tied to someone else’s identity. Many scammer profiles use stolen images. If you find the same photo on a stock photo site or linked to a different name on Facebook, run the other way. Then, there are apps like Social Catfish that can simplify this process for you and give you the lowdown on a person’s background in a matter of minutes
• Beware of malicious links or files: Another scam red flag – your chatmate sends you a file to “view my private pics” or a link like “check out this funny video.” These could be malware or phishing links. Do not click on unfamiliar links sent by a dating app match, no matter how curious you are. They might lead to pages that steal your login or infect your device. If a link is ever necessary, have them tell you the account name or something you can navigate to yourself safely

6. Be careful with what you share 

In the heat of a flirty conversation, you might be tempted to share spicy photos or divulge deeply personal things. It’s important to remember that anything you send to someone could potentially be saved, shared, or used against you later. This isn’t meant to scare you off from intimacy, but to ensure you only share what you’re prepared to live with being public. Even on apps that promise “disappearing” messages or photos, screenshots or other devices can capture that info. And if your relationship sours, an unscrupulous person might misuse what you shared. To protect your digital footprint and reputation, follow these simple internet dating safety tips:

• Think twice before sending explicit content: Once a nude or intimate photo leaves your phone, you lose control over it. The person on the other end might respect your privacy… or they might not. Leaked intimate images (sometimes called “revenge porn”, when an ex shares them) are unfortunately common. If you do choose to sext or send revealing pics, only do it with someone you trust deeply and preferably on a platform that at least has strong privacy controls. Even better, consider using apps like Snapchat or Signal that have self-destruct timers and notify you of screenshots, though these aren’t foolproof either. If you feel uneasy at all, don’t send it. You can always flirt via text in suggestive ways without camera involvement
• Use encryption for sensitive conversations: If you’re discussing very personal topics like mental health, past traumas, or finances with a new partner online, it might be wise to use an end-to-end encrypted messaging app. This means even if someone intercepts the data or if the service is breached, your actual conversation content stays safe. Dating apps themselves vary in security; assume that your messages on them could be seen by the company, at least if not others. An encrypted app adds extra privacy for important conversations
• Don’t share documents or passwords: This might sound obvious, but needs to be reiterated—never share things like your SSN, credit card numbers, bank info, passport scans, with someone you met online. Scammers aside, even a well-meaning partner doesn’t need those in the early stages. Also, don’t hand over passwords to any accounts. Sometimes catfishers will ask for your social media login “to prove you’re real” – that’s a trap. Keep all such info to yourself
• Be mindful of long-term record: The internet never forgets. That lengthy email you wrote, pouring your heart out, or the cloud backup of your chat, could be sitting somewhere indefinitely. It’s wise to periodically clean up. Delete old conversations from your devices if you don’t need them. If you break up or stop talking to someone, consider clearing that chat history. Less data stored means less data that can leak. Also, check if the dating app lets you delete or download your data when you’re done with it.

7. Adjust privacy settings and use app features to your advantage

Every major dating app has some settings you can tweak for privacy, and it’s worth digging into those menus. By default, platforms might expose more info than you realize. For instance, showing your profile to everyone in a 50-mile radius, or indicating when you’re online. In a city as large as New York, you might want to refine who can even see you on these apps. Moreover, new features are constantly being added, focused on safety. Make them work for you.

• Turn off location precision if possible: Some apps allow you to hide your exact distance. If you’re a woman in Manhattan, do all users really need to know you’re “within 1 mile”, which could pinpoint you to a particular neighborhood? Check if the app lets you blur or approximate your location. If not, you might consider setting your location to a general area or a neighboring location. This prevents random people on the app from figuring out exactly where you live or work
• Use Incognito or private modes: Certain services let you browse profiles invisibly or only show your profile to people you “like” first, often as a premium feature. If you’re concerned about privacy or you have a public-facing job and don’t want clients stumbling on your profile, these modes can be a boon. It means you’re not visible to everyone by default. You can take charge of who sees you
• Disable account linking and address book matching: Many apps try to get you to link your Facebook or contacts to “find friends” or show mutual connections. Avoid this if you can. It can leak info both ways. You might inadvertently show your profile to colleagues or Facebook friends. Unless you explicitly want that, keep accounts separate. Also, most apps have an option to prevent others from finding you by phone number or name; use those settings for extra privacy
• Opt-out of data sharing: Some free apps make money by sharing some user data with third-party advertisers. Poke around in settings for any privacy or ad preferences. You might be able to limit ad tracking or data usage. It’s also good to periodically purge your profile of info that’s not needed
• Set messaging filters or preferences: If the app allows, adjust who can message you. For instance, Bumble allows only women to initiate contact in hetero matches, which cuts down on random, creepy DMs. Others have filters for certain keywords or the ability to auto-block messages from people much older/younger than your range. Use these tools so you see more of what you want, less of what you don’t. Your mental peace will improve when your inbox isn’t full of unwanted advances

8. Prioritize your emotional safety and set boundaries

Last but arguably most important safety for online dating tip: protect your emotional well-being throughout the online dating process. Dating, especially in a fast-paced scene like NYC, can take a serious emotional toll if you’re not mindful. The rush of new connections can sometimes cloud judgment, and the sting of ghosting or betrayal can hurt deeply. Feeling unsafe or violated online can trigger anxiety, stress, or even trauma. So, as you practice digital safety, also practice self-care and boundary-setting. You deserve to feel secure both physically and emotionally.

• Trust your gut feelings: If someone you’re chatting with makes you uncomfortable, even if you can’t articulate exactly why, give yourself permission to take a step back or cut it off. You do not owe anyone endless patience or explanations if you feel uneasy. Your intuition is a product of subtle cues; listen to it. Ending a chat or unmatching early can save you from bigger problems later. In the words of therapist Tracie Zinman-Ibrahim, “Thinking is only productive if there’s an attainable goal, and the goal is something that makes sense, like safety. Anything else is just extra…”
• Set boundaries on communication: It’s okay to set limits like “I don’t respond to messages after midnight” or “I won’t send certain photos.” Communicate your boundaries when needed. A respectful match will accept them; an abusive or pushy person will try to bulldoze them, and then you know they’re trouble. Boundaries also include pacing: you don’t have to meet in person until you’re ready, and you don’t have to share anything you’re not comfortable with. No true connection will demand you betray your comfort for them
• Take breaks to avoid burnout: The sheer volume of people and chats on dating apps can be overwhelming. If you find yourself exhausted, anxious, or jaded from swiping, step away for a while. It could be a few days off the app, or limiting yourself to a couple of chats at a time. Burnout can weaken your resolve and make you ignore red flags. By staying mentally fresh, you’ll make better decisions and also present your best self
• Seek support if something goes wrong: If you do experience harassment, stalking, or any form of abuse through online dating, reach out for help. This could mean reporting the user to the app, telling friends/family, or even involving law enforcement if you feel threatened. There are also organizations and hotlines for victims of online abuse. You should never feel like you have to deal with it alone. Talking to a therapist can help if an incident leaves you shaken

Takeaway

To navigate the online dating scene in NYC successfully, you need to balance openness with caution. Applying these secure messaging, privacy, and online dating safety tips can help you strike that delicate balance. Remember, you’re not being overly careful, you’re valuing your safety above all else. You have every right to protect your personal information, your digital accounts, and your emotional well-being as you meet new people. 

Scammers, hackers, and creeps will always be out there, but with smart habits and tools like a trusted VPN, strong passwords, and a good dose of common sense, you can enjoy the adventure of online dating with far less risk. Stay safe, keep your guard and your heart balanced, and happy swiping! 

Your contribution does not constitute a charitable donation. It will allow Bonobology to continue bringing you new and up-to-date information in our pursuit of helping anyone in the world to learn how to do anything.

See Our Editorial Process

Meet Our Review Board

Share Feedback

What is your feedback?

×

Helpful Report an Error Other

Submit